asian-actionfilm.news
Archives













Home | Article Page | Interview Page | Reviews Page | Contact | Archives





Bruce Lee vs. Jackie Chan: who was better?

 

Other Topics:

Jackie's Biography

Bruce Lee

Some of Jackie’s top Stunts

Jackie’s top fights

Fighting Choreography: Jackie vs. Samo Hung

 

 

I will answer in a very straightforward manner. Jackie was a better stuntman and comedian but Bruce was a true martial arts master. Lee used filmmaking to prove and to demonstrate his fighting theories while Jackie exaggerates often by adding wild stunts and a lot of wire work. If you watch Jackie fight, you will be entertained but when you watch Bruce, you might learn something.

Jackie appeared in Bruce Lee's breakthrough classic Enter the Dragon, as one of the numerous people Bruce fights off. Although only on the screen briefly, Jackie's face can clearly be seen.
As Jackie said himself after his success, Bruce Lee could not be replaced.

Bruce and Jackie in "Enter the dragon"

Jackie Chan’s top fights

 

Other Topics:

Jackie's Biography.

Some of Jackie’s top Stunts.

Fighting Choreography: Jackie vs. Samo Hung.

Bruce Lee vs. Jackie Chan: who was better?


“Wheels on Meals” - 1984

This was his first face-off with American champion kickboxer Benny "The Jet" Urquidez. This is one of the best fights ever filmed. Benny is a great fighter and a legend --good enough that he tested Jackie’s skills to the limit. In fact, throughout the filming of this scene, Jackie teased him that they should fight a real match, not just a movie brawl. "Come on, Benny, let's do it," he'd say. And Benny would say, "Any time, Jackie, any time." Well, the time was always "sometime soon," and by the time the film was finished, he finally caught on that Jackie was just joking. “To be honest, I don't know who would have won if we did fight. He's that good”, Jackie says. OK, Jackie, you are good but he is the real thing. Don’t even think about trying to get in the ring with this guy.


“Dragons Forever” - 1987

Jackie Chan, Samo Hung and Yuen Biao.

This is the third and last movie that Jackie and his opera brothers, Samo and Yuen Biao, co-starred in. It is also the only film where the three brothers fight against one another.
The final fight of this movie is also one of the best-shot action sequences that Samo Hung has ever directed. The pacing of this second battle with Benny "The Jet" Urquidez is wonderful, too, beginning slow with each of the fighters sizing up the other while they take off their shirts and circle warily, and then building tremendous momentum into a whirlwind of kicks and punches. Truly a classic mixed martial arts moment that has everything. No American made movie has ever managed to capture fight sequences half as good as these two.


“Drunken Master” - 1978
This film portrayed a traditional theme about a well-known Kung Fu Master, Wong Fei-Hung, in a very creative way. Jackie acts the part of the young Wong who was very rebellious and finally learnt the art of "drunk boxing". The film retained the successful elements of “Snake in the Eagle's Shadow” and introduced humour at the same time. The outcome was phenomenal, and since then Jackie has become a superstar.
Jackie faces off in the finale of his first big box-office smash against Hwang Jang Lee, a Korean martial artist who is one of the greatest kickers in the history of kung fu cinema. It's an intense and unusual fight, featuring his comical "Eight Drunken Fairies" drunken-style fighting against Hwang's tae kwon do: fast, funny, and furious. On “Drunken Master,” his brow ridge was injured, and he nearly lost an eye.

“Police Story” -1985

“Police Story” was Jackie's favourite action movie and several sequels were afterwards made. The many amazing stunts included a hillside car chase and sliding down a 70-foot pole wrapped in Christmas lights in a shopping centre. Success didn't come without suffering; both of Jackie's hands were seriously burnt. Jackie is fast and furious in this film and plays an unstoppable police officer. In the final fight he uses his “anything goes” style against a lot of thugs. No Hollywood movie - no matter the budget - has ever captured this kind of action on film.

“Police Story II” -1988

An example of intricate prop fighting, in which he uses playground equipment to take out a gang of thugs. Think of a complicated dance with a whole bunch of partners, over, under, through, and around swing sets, jungle gyms, and seesaws, and you'll get a small piece of the picture here.

“Armour of God” -1986

One of the black amazons.

A bizarre battle between Jackie and a mob of angry monks, with a few warrior women thrown in for good measure. Jackie perfected his "one-man-against-the-world" fighting style in this crazy fight, battling outward in a spiral while using circular kicks to keep the cassock-wearing combatants at a distance. His fight against the black amazons is very spectacular and original.

“The Young Master” –1980

In this epic, extended battle, Jackie fights hapkido expert Whang Inn Sik. He was very impressed with his martial arts, and was determined to show the audience the power and beauty of this Korean fighting style. As a result, Jackie shot the entire scene at a wide angle with relatively few cuts. To finally defeat the master, Jackie throws out all of his traditional techniques, and just goes at him like a lunatic, flailing his arms and smashing into him with his head, his fists, and every other part of his body. He does win in the end, but at a price: the last scene of the movie shows him in a complete body cast, waving goodbye with his fingers! During “The Young Master,” he was almost suffocated when he injured his throat. Also you might think that ‘Someone Up There’ had it in for Jackie and his nose! It's bad enough that it's so big to begin with, but he has actually broken it at least three times--one of them was the “Young Master” (the others were “Project A,” and, most recently, “Mr. Nice Guy”).

“Dragon Lord” -1982

Wang Inn-Sik

“ Dragon Lord,” nominated the Best Action Design, Hong Kong Film Awards, 1982, was originally intended as the sequel to “Young Master” but was soon considered a story in its own right. The movie didn't sell well in Hong Kong but was widely accepted and very popular in Japan. Jackie fights Wang Inn-Sik, the Hapkido master for the second time. Jackie injured his chin on “Dragon Lord.” It was painful even talking for a while which made it hard to direct, not to mention act. Wang Inn-Sik is Bruce Lee’s Japanese opponent in “Way of the Dragon”
Director: Jackie Chan.

“Project A” - 1984

This movie was the first time the three "brothers", Jackie, Samo and Yuen Biao, co-starred in a movie together. Jackie was the director and they had plenty of dangerous stunts such as the famous jump from the clock tower. The three were a winning combination; the movie made HK$14 million in its first week at the box office. The movies they worked on together always enjoyed great success. Jackie, Yuen Biao and Samo Hung fight together in an epic battle against a fearsome pirate played by Dik Wei (one of my favorite Hong Kong actors that usually plays the villain).

Dik Wei


“Heart of Dragon” - 1985

Very different from the traditional Jackie movies, this film focused on the relationship of the brotherhood rather than on Kung Fu fighting. Westerners saw it as the action version of “Rain Man”. This is a boring movie but the final fight scene against Dik Wei is awesome.

“City Hunter” - 1993

Jackie and Gary Daniels.

In this movie, produced primarily for the Japanese market, Jackie acts as the funny, joke-cracking cartoon character, Meng Po. Jackie fights against Richard Norton and Gary Daniels. The movie has very good fights but it has a very crazy script

“Gorgeous” - 1999

Unlike his usual brand of movies, this passionate movie marks an attempt by Jackie to try something different from stunts and action. The film is full of small delights and the action scenes are cleverly inserted. It also has the right kind of martial artist spirit, getting into fights without being vicious. Jackie fights against Bradley James Allan . Brad is an Australian fight choreographer and stuntman and is the first ever foreigner to become a member of the Sing Ga Ban. He has trained under Master Liang Chang Xing, who was, along with Jet Li, a former member of the Beijing Wushu team. I first noticed Brad Allan in “Gorgeous,” and I was hooked. From the first moves he made, I saw that this guy truly was a great martial artist. Incidentally, Brad was the bodyguard for Jackie while he was promoting "Who am I?" in Japan.

Bruce Lee's "Way of the Dragon" is one of several re-issue titles for Lee's "Return of the Dragon". Filmed in Rome and Hong Kong, this exhilarating adventure flick finds Lee battling Chuck Norris, in one of the latter's few unsympathetic roles. The climax pits Lee against Norris in the middle of the Roman Coliseum! Directed by Bruce Lee himself (who exhibits an unsuspected flair for comedy), "Return of the Dragon" was the last "complete" Lee vehicle.
 

 
The fight between the two of them is, in my opinion, the most sophisticated fight ever captured on film. It may not look as stylish as some Jackie Chan or Jet Li fights but that is only the surface. Deep down this fighting sequence uses all the wisdom and martial arts knowledge that made Bruce Lee a legend. It was the first time that Bruce Lee as writer, producer and director had the creative freedom to do whatever he wished. The result is a final gladiatorial duel with 7 times world karate champion, Chuck Norris in the Coliseum. Two worlds collide in this fight: Chuck’s modern karate style fighting and Jeet Kune Do. If there were a martial arts film museum, this fight would be in it. A fighter can learn more about every aspect of fighting by studying this fight than by studying hundreds of real fights. In this movie you can see a combination of all Jeet Kune Do theories: timing, traping, rhythm, distance control, the element of surprise etc. Also in this scene there are no wires or acrobatics. This is pure martial arts wisdom in action. Need I say more?

Other Topics:

Jackie's Biography

Jackie’s top fights

Fighting Choreography: Jackie vs. Samo Hung

Bruce Lee vs. Jackie Chan: who was better?


His worst injury ever, "Armour of God"

Anyone who's a fan of Jackie’s movies knows that if he watches the films to the very end, he'll get a sort of ghoulish treat: a selection of his "no-goods," out-takes from stunts and fight sequences that just didn't work out right. A lot of times the result is an injury, and sometimes a bad one. His very worst injury ever, the one that almost killed him, actually occurred on a very routine stunt. He was shooting “Armour of God” in Yugoslavia, and was still recovering from the jet lag of flying twenty hours to get there. The stunt was simple-just jumping down from a castle wall to a tree below. The first time he tried it, the stunt went perfectly, but he wasn't satisfied with the take. He tried it again, and the second time, he somehow missed the branch he was trying to grab. He fell past the tree and onto the ground below. Actually, there was a cameraman down there trying to capture a low angle, and if he hadn't scrambled out of the way, Jackie would have probably landed on him. They would both have been hurt, but not badly. Instead, he hit the rocky ground, head first. A piece of his skull cracked and shot up into his brain, and blood poured from his ears. The production team quickly got on the phones to try to find the nearest hospital that could do emergency brain surgery, and eight hours later, he was going under the knife. The operation was successful, and Jackie recovered quickly - even though there's a permanent hole in his head now, with a plastic plug there to keep his brains in.
The “Armour of God” fall also left him hard-of-hearing in one ear.


The Great Glass Slide, " Police Story”

As far as action is concerned, “Police Story” is Jackie’s favourite movie that he ever made, a real whirlwind of slam-bang stunts and wild fights from beginning to end.
There is a point in the movie where he finally puts the drop on the gangsters once and for all. Of course, he had to put the drop on himself in order to do it--literally. After a glass-shattering fight inside a shopping mall, he spotted his target several floors below, on the ground level of an open atrium. The only way to get down from his perch in time to do his policeman's duty was to take a flying leap into the air, grab a hold of a pole wrapped in twinkling Christmas lights, and slide a hundred feet to the ground--through a glass-and-wood partition, onto the hard marble tile. He had to do this in one take, so he crossed his fingers and prayed that he'd hit the stunt the first time (and that he'd hit the ground softly). He made his jump, grabbed the pole, and watched the twinkling lights crack and pop all the way down, in an explosion of shattering glass and electrical sparks. Then he hit the glass. And then he hit the floor. Somehow he managed to survive with a collection of ugly bruises ... and second-degree burns on the skin of his fingers and palms. He has had a lot of back injuries doing his movies, but the pole-slide scene in “Police Story” almost paralyzed him when he nearly broke the seventh and eighth vertebrae in his spine.


Clock Tower Tumble, “Project A”

After a wild bicycle chase through Hong Kong's back alleys, Jackie finds himself high in the air, dangling from the hands of a giant clock face. With no other way to get down than fall, he let go--and crashed through a series of cloth canopies before smashing into the ground. He had to do this one three times before he was satisfied with the way it looked. “I wouldn't want to do it a fourth time”, he says smiling. Jackie has hurt his neck a lot, but one of his worst neck injuries happened during the clock-tower fall in “Project A.”


No Way to Ride a Bus, “Police Story II”

Another chase sequence--this time running along the tops of moving buses, while narrowly dodging signs and billboards that pass overhead and around him. At the end of the chase, he leaps through a glass window.... Unfortunately, he chose the wrong window as his target, and instead of hitting prop glass, he smashed through a real pane which left him in real “pain.”

Going Down ... in “Who Am I?”

This scene was billed by Jackie’s producers as the "world's most dangerous stunt." They were probably telling the truth--although just about any of Jackie’s stunts is dangerous, if you do it wrong. (The stunt that nearly killed him took place less than fifteen feet off the ground, after all.) Luckily, he did it right. Eventually. Even though one of his stuntmen proved it could be done (from a lower level, of course), it took him two weeks to get up the nerve to try it himself. The sequence begins with him fighting it out with some thugs on the top of a very tall building in Rotterdam, Holland. After battling with them around the roof, and nearly falling off once or twice, he finally took the quickest possible trip to the sidewalk below --sliding down the side of the building, which is slanted nearly forty-five degrees, all the way to the ground. Twenty-one stories.